Definitiv Professional
York City win
draw
Carlisle United win
| League 2 | 14/11/2026 | Rochdale | 0 1 | York City | |||
| FA Cup | 07/11/2026 | York City | 4 0 | Northampton Town | |||
| League 2 | 31/10/2026 | Grimsby | 5 2 | York City | |||
| League 2 | 27/10/2026 | Barnet | 3 1 | York City | |||
| League 2 | 24/10/2026 | York City | 2 0 | Port Vale |
| FA Cup | 07/11/2026 | Carlisle United | 1 0 | Salford City | |||
| FA Cup | 07/12/2025 | Blackpool | 4 1 | Carlisle United | |||
| FA Cup | 01/11/2025 | Reading | 2 3 | Carlisle United | |||
| AET Carlisle win 3-2 | |||||||
| League 2 | 03/05/2025 | Carlisle United | 2 2 | Salford City | |||
| League 2 | 26/04/2025 | Cheltenham | 3 2 | Carlisle United | |||
BOTH TEAMS TO SCORE
BOTH TEAMS TO SCORE IN THE FIRST HALF
BOTH TEAMS TO SCORE IN THE SECOND HALF
YORK CITY TO SCORE FIRST
CARLISLE UNITED TO SCORE FIRST
final score 1-0
final score 2-0
final score 1-1
| League 2 | 23/01/2016 | Carlisle United | 1 1 | York City | Brunton Park | |||
| League 2 | 19/09/2015 | York City | 2 2 | Carlisle United | Bootham Crescent |